How did you use media technologies in the construction, research, planning and evaluation stages? I used a slide share to present my answer to this question
What have you learnt from your audience feedback? Getting the feedback: For
this evaluation question, I have managed to get the opinions of people who have looked at my products using a sound recording.
This allowed me to replay my audience feedback so I could understand then evaluate it. Firstly, I showed members of my audience my music video.
Next, I did the same but looked at the ancillary task.
From listening to these recordings, I managed to pick up good audience feedback allowing me to be able to successfully evaluate my task.
As well as asking people what they thought of my products, I also did a questionnaire, which allows anonymous comments from many who have seen it. Instead of posting many photos, I wanted to make my feedback more interesting. I therefore, created another video which would allow me to put all of my answers to my questionnaire in one place.
Quantitative data was also found:
I have shown examples of this below:
Response to the feedback: I found many ways to get audience feedback (all of which were extremely helpful) and below are the things I have found have come up most often:
The Actresses. Many of the comments, especially written in the questionnaire, commented on the acting being 'poor' or 'not as good as it could be'. Although we have seen this as an issue through our project, we did not have a lot of choice when it came to actresses. TO OVER COME THIS PROBLEM, we tried to use short clips through out editing and used close ups. This meant that our actresses did not have to act that much, instead we could use their eyes and facial expressions to convey our story and emotion.
The Target Audience. When listening to the voice recordings especially, I noticed that my video and products seem to appeal to a younger generation (mostly of females). This is great feedback as this is exactly the audience we wanted to address. Within the questionnaires the person with the Pink pen was a teenage girl who listened to pop music. From her very positive feedback, I can see that our video has reached the target audience we wanted to.
Connection
between the song and the story line.Many of my audience have noticed the connection between the song lyrics and our story (something which is extremely important). Many said that
they linked well. This is something that I rate as extremely successful in
the project. I believe they link very well as the music lyrics revolve around the idea that Alice cannot make herself 'perfect' no matter how hard she tries. P!NK's lyrics portray the idea that being perfect is not about your looks but she emphasizes the idea that you are perfect the way you are.
Connection between the Video and the Ancillary tasks. Something that we tried very hard to ensure through our
project was that our video linked with our ancillary tasks. Through my
audience feedback, I have been told that this link is very
successful. However, it could be improved through use of a black and white video. This would allow the video to directly link with the video. Further comment of this is available in Evaluation Question number 2.
The Back Cover of the Digi-Pack.This
appears to have been the most popular part of the Digi-pack. The use of
the black back ground, the strong image, and the realistic CD features are
something that has appeared to attract my audience. This has allowed them
to give me positive feedback, something I was hoping to get.
How effective is the combination of your main product and ancillary texts?
I believe that is was essential that our ancillary task linked to our video. This would mean that audiences would be advertised to our video.
I will use Adele as the example we used to help to ensure that our video linked to our ancillary task.
Both of the above songs are from Adele's album 21. In our creations, we have tried to use real products in order to see how our own video could link to our digi-pak and magazine advert. Below I will state the features which allow the combination of our main product and ancillary texts to be effective and successful. The Use of Make-up is largely used without our video to represent Alice's inner character. The black make up reflects the idea that Alice is rather depressed, darkened by her own faults. The make up also allows her eyes to stand out, capturing her deep emotions. By using the same make-up in the ancillary task, we are able to express the SAME emotions and depressing. It allows a direct link. Using running make-up on the magazine advert allows further connection. As Alice is in the bath, the use of the make up running down her face expresses her giving up. It could almost be seen as her AFTER the suicide. The clothing and hair is the same in both the video and the ancillary tasks. This ensures that the combination is realistic. The hair especially was used in an effective way in my opinion. By having it quit large in the photographs on our ancillary tasks, I believe that we are able to present her wild character. Her committing suicide is a rather bold move. This is something we believe we could reflect through the use of quite wild hair (and again, a lot of make up). The body language of Alice is something we tried to keep similar within all of our products. Within the video, we used actions that would display that of frustration or depression. This included having Alice have her hands on her head and running her fingers through hair. This is an action that we believed was regularly connected to anger and upset. We found this through our research.
The name of the song on the back cover is very effective. Like many artists, we have put Alice's 'main single' Perfect as the first single on the album. This linked to our research of Adele, Rihanna and others. This is an effective feature as our audience will be able to look at the songs and instantly recognize the first song. I believe this is important when it comes to promoting and advertising our product. By putting ours as the first song, there is a major and obvious link.
I will use slide point to present my findings in picture form. This allows me to present the evidence of what I have discussed.
All together, I believe that the video and the ancillary tasks really link well together. The images of Alice on the Digi-pack and ancillary task mirror Alice's character within the video. As stated in some of the other evaluation questions, making the video itself black and white would improve the connection between tasks. The Ancillary Tasks all link together extremely well. This is because we have ensured to use the same font and the same colour scheme. Shown below is how the two ancillary tasks have linked.
All of this process is shown in the editing process of my blog. I believe it was rather easy to keep my two ancillary tasks connected. I believe we have been very effective in remaining continuity.
In what ways does your media product use, develop or challenge form and conventions of real media products?
I have looked far into real media products throughout the project to ensure my own work remains professional, realistic and interesting. You tube was very beneficial for my research. First, I will show how my media product uses, develops or challenges forms and conventions of real media.
To see how my products relate to real media, I have gone back to my previous research. I searched many videos on you tube and used features of these videos in my own. Examples are shown below:
Looking at the eyes of the characters within the music videos, I saw that a lot of emotion can be expressed through just the eyes. I wanted to adapt this into my product. (Something I believe I have done). Using just the eyes of characters means that the acting of my actress is not as much of a concern.
Close ups are used in many ways as they allow the camera to tell a story through use of facial expression. By looking down, a character appears as feeling hopeless and as if they cannot continue on. Shown above are examples of how I have used real media and developed it to make my own products. Having Alice looking down a lot throughout the video allows a feel of sadness and little hope for an audience.
As shown here, I also took ideas for setting from my real products. Through looking at real products, I noticed that the bathroom seemed to be a place where characters were most depressed. I assume this is due to this being the place in which people are most private with themselves. No one can see them so therefore, we can feel their inner feelings. The use of the bath allows a character to reflect over their life. I believe having Alice in the bath by the end of our video was very successful in portraying her thinking over her life. (Flashbacks are shown here to further mirror this).
As well as setting, I was able to gain ideas to improve and develop my own story line. Within many of the videos I researched, I saw that when depressed, the character tends to try and change something about themselves whilst at the mirror. In the examples I have shown here, the top especially shows the character trying to change herself (hoping this will help). I decided to have Alice put on her make up and then angrily wipe it off. I believe this would reflect how nothing she does helps with the negativity she feels about herself.
In contrast to the stories on the left, a lot of videos portray this attempt at inner change as successful. However, for our video, we have shown Alice doing her make up as being hopeless. She does not feel any better portraying that no matter what she does, her depression will remain. One thing I noticed is that many of the depressing music videos such as Adeles 'someone like you' and Beyonce's 'if I were a boy' is that their videos are in Black and White. This is an effective technique as it means that the emotions of the character stands out clearly. If we had further discussed this idea as a group we may have changed the colour of our video. It would also cause it to link more to our ancillary tasks which are in black and white. However, our colouring (especially in the bathroom) is already quite dark and seems to have a type of grey-scale effect. Therefore, it is not a major problem.
From my video research I was able to see key features, themes and settings (these are presented through the word cloud below).
Next, I looked at my ancillary task. Addressing the real products for these products is something I have done a lot during the entire blog. Therefore, more can be found by looking at the label of 'comparing real media and our products'.
Shown above are examples of how I went from real products to create my own. I believe I successfully stayed on task and all my products relate. Black and White imagery is used in our all of our digi-pack and magazine advert which relates directly to our research (especially of Adele).
Adeles album:
Adeles album '21' has been the most beneficial album to link our work to as we believe Adele expresses the same kind of emotion we want in our own product. Sticking to looking at real products allowed us to ensure that our product remained professional and looked realistic My audience feedback allowed me to see that our Digi-pack (especially the back cover) looked like a real product. This is all we have been trying to achieve.
The controversial scene:
The outdoor scene when Alice admits her love to Jessie is one that our group added in in order to challenge conventions of media products. We did not want to create a typical love story where a girl falls out with her boyfriend. From our teachers advice, this would be rather bland and too similar to many other music videos. We wanted to do something different. By adding homosexuality into our video, we address a topic that is sometimes sensitive to work with. However, we believe it worked well, increasing the drama in our product.
Realism:
I believe we could have improve the realism of our product is if we had better choice of equipment and more time. It would be very beneficial for us to have a camera that we could easily use whenever we wanted. However, it was a piece of equipment from school. This meant that we had limited time with it. I still believe that our video and ancillary task have remained rather professional, generally, sticking to the normal conventions of media products.
Now,
we wanted to complete the second ancillary task. This meant that we needed to
create a magazine advert for our project.
For
our magazine advert, we wanted a photo that expressed Alice using more body
language. The image we picked is shown below. We ensured to use the same make
up and clothing which is present on the back of the CD cover. We also ensured
to link our advert with our film as she is holding her hair back (something she
does regularly in the video):
Again, we wanted to ensure continuity throughout our
products. We therefore, decided to make the photograph black and white (just
like the digi-pack). We did this in Photoshop.
Like the background to our CD cover, we wanted to have a
dark, black background. By using the 'paint' tool and the 'eraser tool' around
the edges of the photograph in order to make the background black.
Some parts of the photo were rather hard to edit like shown
below:
We wanted to put the photo intoIndesign to see how much the
outline of the photograph stands out. We will probably have to put it into
photo-shop again to edit the photograph further.
As shown, the image is still not professional looking.
Therefore, we went back into photo-shop in order to further edit.
We were able to create a spacing around the image of Alice
using the 'eraser' tool. This function allowed us to give a smudge effect
around Alice, highlighting her.
When going back to in-design, we had a problem that the top
of the image was too sharp, it did not look professional (this is highlighted
below).
To solve this problem, we decided to decrease the size of
the magazine advert, allowing us to get rid of the sharp cut at the top of the
photograph. This did not cause a problem all of the key information still fit
onto the page.
We tried to keep strong continuity throughout all of our
ancillary task by keeping the colour scheme, fonts and outfit of Alice the
same. Our first draft is shown below:
After having feedback from our teachers and class mates, we realized that this poster does not look professional enough. The smudge around Alice was not thought of as a nice feature. Therefore, we have decided to get rid of this:
To get rid of the smudged white line, we went back into 'Photoshop' and used the 'eraser' tool. Some parts were very difficult to edit as we wanted to ensure not to accidentally erase any of Alice's arm.
By then putting the photo back into 'In-design', we decided to add more typical magazine features to the poster.
By looking back at our research, we focused on Olly Murs' which allowed us to see the major use of Red and also comments on the 'debut album'. We thought this was very effective (shown below) and therefore, used his feature on our own.
Another feature we have decided to use is the use of red. This is something that was discussed earlier on. With our feedback, we decided to add this as a feature. As well as this, we decided to add on some ratings from magazines on our advert. This makes it look more real. By using real magazine names, we can increase the realism of our product.
Shown below, highlighted in red are the new features we have added. We used the same Font throughout our products.
As well as making sure it relates to our research, we have ensured the advert links to our other ancillary products too.